Woman walking around store on her phone

Is Online Shopping Really Better? Items to Consider Buying Offline

May 17, 2023

In this digital age, online shopping has become the norm for many of us. However, it's worth noting that there are instances where buying in brick-and-mortar stores can be advantageous. Surprisingly, certain items are still more affordable when purchased in person, just like in the old days. Here are some considerations to keep in mind when deciding between online and offline shopping.

1. Toys

If you're on the hunt for the latest and greatest toy for your little one, try exploring physical stores. According to a report from USA Today, offline toy prices have experienced a significant decline of 34 percent over the past five years. In comparison, online prices have only dropped by 25 percent. The closure of Toys-R-Us had a notable impact on this trend. When the store discounted toys in an attempt to salvage its business (which ultimately failed), other retailers felt compelled to follow suit. Another reason why toys tend to be cheaper in physical stores is the expense associated with shipping. Online companies must accommodate various toy sizes, necessitating different packaging solutions, which ultimately drive up their shipping costs.

2. Perishable foods

Similar to toys, perishable goods such as milk and produce incur higher shipping costs, leading to elevated online prices. Over the past five years, online grocery prices have increased by 3.4 percent, while offline prices have risen by a slightly lower 2.8 percent. Opting to purchase perishable goods in person offers the advantage of ensuring freshness while also yielding cost savings.

3. Non-prescription drugs

The next time you find yourself in need of over-the-counter medicine, consider visiting a nearby drug store. Since 2014, prices at physical stores have experienced a 2 percent decline, whereas online prices have actually risen by 1.7 percent. One reason for the higher online prices is the appeal of convenience. However, it's worth noting that prices for over-the-counter drugs can vary significantly depending on the location, so it's advisable to shop around before having your prescription filled.

4. Large Appliances

In-store purchases of large appliances like refrigerators, washing machines, or televisions may allow you to negotiate the price or take advantage of special in-store promotions and discounts. Additionally, you can avoid shipping fees or additional costs associated with online delivery.

5. Furniture

Furniture prices can vary significantly depending on the quality, brand, and store. Shopping in-store allows you to explore clearance sales, discounted floor models, or negotiate prices with sales representatives, potentially leading to better deals compared to online shopping.

6. Local Services

Services such as home repairs, renovations, or professional consultations are often best obtained in-store or through local providers. Meeting service providers face-to-face allows you to negotiate prices, discuss specific requirements, and potentially find better rates or package deals.

7. Bulk Purchases

When buying items in bulk, such as groceries, office supplies, or household essentials, in-store shopping can offer better deals, especially if you have access to membership stores or warehouse clubs. These stores often provide discounted prices or special offers for bulk purchases.

8. Clearance or Seasonal Items

In-store shopping can be advantageous for clearance sales and seasonal items. Retailers often offer significant discounts on out-of-season merchandise, holiday decorations, or end-of-line products, which may not be as readily available or discounted online.

9. Negotiable Items

Items that are commonly subject to negotiation, such as vehicles, antiques, or high-end electronics, can be better purchased in-store. Face-to-face interactions allow you to negotiate the price directly with the seller, potentially securing a better deal than what is available online.

While these items may be more favorable to purchase in-store based on price considerations, it's always a good idea to compare prices, read reviews, and consider other factors like convenience, availability, and personal preferences before making a final decision.

While these items may be more favorable to purchase in-store based on price considerations, it's always a good idea to compare prices, read reviews, and consider other factors like convenience, availability, and personal preferences before making a final decision. 

About the Author

Kayla Boomsma

Kayla Boomsma is a Personal Banker in the retail department at our 26th St. location in Sioux Falls.